Buy or Rent : The Cardinal Housing Dilemma

65

By Abhishek87

Nolo's Essential Guide to Buying Your First Home
Amazon Price: $14.93
List Price: $24.99
Home Buying For Dummies, 4th Edition
Amazon Price: $9.09
List Price: $21.99
The Essential Handbook for Buying a Home
Amazon Price: $2.99
Home Buying, Everything You Must Know
Amazon Price: $4.99

I used to think of buying a house as a very good investment till I came across this hub by Jamagenee on why the author rents instead of owning. The hub got me thinking as to how to solve the dilemma. We'll be discussing the pros and cons for both of the options but ultimately the decision has to be yours.

Hasn't buying a home always been THE Dream, so why the sudden interest in renting, you might say. Well, in the times of the  real estate boom, with ultra low interest rates and plethora of mortgage options, people went on a buying spree that raised  housing rates to unprecedented and largely unrealistic levels while the rise in rents was comparatively so nominal that renting was the new buzzword of the town. But the present scenario has seemed to level things with everything falling off the cliff. And hence we ponder over the dilemma of buying vs. renting:

BUYING: Can I / Should I / Will I  ???

Buying a house is a lifestyle choice as well as a financial one and comes with its own sets of benefits and detriments...

·         Appreciation: When we talk about appreciation, there is usually an 'if' attached... If your property appreciates, you make a tidy profit but you make not so tidy loss  too if it depreciates. What we have to consider here is that, in the long run property Does appreciate 9 out of 10 times. And by the long run is meant a period of around 10  years at least. Buying something and expecting it to appreciate overnight is gambling, not investing and I don't gamble with my life's savings.

·         Tax deductions: This is one reason you'll find buying advocates shouting over and over again. When you buy a house,  the interest you pay on your mortgage is tax-deductible, you can also claim property taxes you pay as an income tax deduction.

·         Tax-Free profits: You can exclude up to $250,000 for an individual or $500,000 for a married couple of profit from capital gains,  as long as you have lived in your home for two of the past five years.

 Of course, because tax rules vary based on income and other factors, be sure to consult an accountant or financial advisor about your particular situation  and the present norms.

·         The Psychological factor: I don’t have to explain what it would feel in your own home; you can paint those walls turn up the music and there is that sense of stability and security that’s elusive in a rented place.

WHY NOT:

Buying a house may turn from a dream to your worst nightmare if you don’t tread with caution. Here's why:

·         Bindings: Think everything out before binding yourself to a cycle of making payments for the next 20-30 years. Make sure that you can handle your finances not only today but also in the downturn markets.

·         Check, Check: You have to keep your payments in check and ideally should not allow them to account for more than 30-33%  of your gross income.

·         Costly affair: The side-effects of buying a house i.e. the extra costs due to repairs, insurance, maintenance etc. are usually a big turnoff.  Keep in mind that these expenses will come along whenever it may be that you decide to buy a house.

NOTE:

CREDIT SCORE: Your credit score is one of the most important things to consider when thinking about a home as it will decide what amount you'll pay for the next decade. Here's a little more detail. 

Ultimately, its you who has to decide whether the time is right for you, if you have the financial   stability and also whether the market is not too overpriced.


Would you Buy or Rent ???

  • Buy
  • Rent
  • Can't Decide
See results without voting

Comments

AEvans profile image

AEvans Level 7 Commenter 3 years ago

I was an owner and wrote it about it on that article, and now we are renters . You are correct there are pros and cons, however the upside for us is that we are not paying $3000.00 a month on a mortgage , the downside is I do miss our home and cried big tears, when the bank made an error and auctioned our home. Yes they made a error we were current , and working on reducing on our mortgage and someone made a mess, thank goodness for attorney's. Great article. :)

Abhishek87 profile image

Abhishek87 Hub Author 3 years ago

Thanks :). Well yes, you may look at any no. of statistics and advice but ultimately it boils down to the financial aspect and the fact that which choice maks you happy.

AEvans profile image

AEvans Level 7 Commenter 3 years ago

Being a homeowner made me happy, but we will be homeowners again.:)

Abhishek87 profile image

Abhishek87 Hub Author 3 years ago

Amen :D

Tom Rubenoff profile image

Tom Rubenoff 3 years ago

We were very lucky to have bought in a very good neighborhood. We have bought condominiums and have enjoyed having a common pocket out of which to pay common expenses.

JamaGenee profile image

JamaGenee Level 8 Commenter 3 years ago

Very good hub, Abhishek. It does boil down to personal choice and situation, also which part of the country one lives in. People on the West Coast who got into overpriced homes they couldn't afford may've fared quite well in the Midwest. But no matter where you live, *always* investigate the true costs of owning before signing on the dotted line. The 30-33% of income rule only applies to the mortgage payment and taxes, not repair/replacement expenses a house will incur on a regular basis.

kiwi91 profile image

kiwi91 3 years ago

For a long time everyone forgot about the 30-33% rule of income. A hard lesson taught in this housing crisis! I currently own, but would've been much better off renting (though I did follow the income rule!). I bought high, now prices are low. The only thing I can do is wait a long time for housing prices to go back up, and who knows how long that will be...but I am confident that they WILL go back up. Rock bottom for the real estate market may still be yet to come though.

Abhishek87 profile image

Abhishek87 Hub Author 3 years ago

You are right, they'll definitely go up. If its the place you live in, its easy to wait compared to if you bought it solely for investment purposes. While buying, you should always consider the long term scenario, like it is stocks if you want to make sure you get out on the positive side.

Lgali profile image

Lgali 3 years ago

nice hub

Lgali profile image

Lgali 3 years ago

nice hub

olliehenderson76 profile image

olliehenderson76 3 years ago

this delimma continues on and on

multimastery profile image

multimastery 3 years ago

Well-written Hub Abhishek! I think that buying can be a good investment for some - but it is a major long-term decision. Personally I can't see it currently for my lifestyle. It's rent for me! Less hassle, no long-term commitment, low maitenance.

realestateuk profile image

realestateuk 3 years ago

As someone into real estate, owning a home remains a good dream. I continue to come across people who are wary, because of the economic slide of late, to get into a long-term payment cycle for their dream home. So maybe one would have to agree with some of the comments here, that buying would really have fit with one's lifestyle, which should be backed up with sound finances. Good pros and cons article, by the way. A good 'checklist'.

Abhishek87 profile image

Abhishek87 Hub Author 3 years ago

Thanks realestateuk. YEs, at the moment it really is hard tfor people to get into the buying mode especially when we have no idea how long this recession may last.

Submit a Comment
Members and Guests

Sign in or sign up and post using a hubpages account.



    • No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked
    • Comments are not for promoting your Hubs or other sites

    Please wait working